Wednesday, 22 November 2017

Sir Edward Law (1846-1908):
the Irish Philhellene who rescued
the Greek economy in the 1890s

Sir Edward FitzGerald Law (1846-1908) … the Philhellene who rescued the Greek economy in the 1890s

Patrick Comerford

The Irish Hellenic Society,

The United Arts Club,

Upper Fitzwilliam Street, Dublin,

7.30pm, 22 November 2017.

Οδός Λω Εδουρδου … named after Edward Law (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

The present financial crisis in Greece, the international consequences of Greek defaulting on its debts, the cycle of daily or weekly protests on the streets of Athens, Thessaloniki and other cities, and the possibility of the government – at some time – defaulting on the Greek national debt, all remind me of the story of Sir Edward FitzGerald Law (1846–1908).

Edward Law was an Irish diplomat who was involved in restructuring Greece’s finances over a century ago. But he became so passionately involved in Greece’s story, that he is still remembered and honoured in Athens today.

In researching the stories of the Irish Philhellenes who contributed to the liberation of Greece in the 19th century, I might have passed by Edward Law’s contribution to making Greece an independent, modern state, except I came across his name by accident on a number of successive occasions, including:

● researching the biographical details of his father’s cousin, the Revd Patrick Comerford Law (1797-1869);

● reading reports of a visit to Athens by his cousin, Archbishop John Fitzgerald Gregg;

● coming across his monument in Saint Patrick’s Cathedral, Dublin;

● visiting the Spire restaurant in Duleek, Co Meath, housed in the former Church of Ireland parish church, and the surrounding churchyard where members of the Law family are buried;

● visiting the street in Athens that is named after him.

Family background

The Bank of Ireland … Michael Law (1795-1858) was a director (Photograph: Patrick Comerford)

The Law family was of Scottish descent, and an ancestor, Michael Law, fought with King William at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690. One branch of the Law family was a long-established clerical family in the Church of Ireland. Michael Law’s son, the Revd William Samuel Law, who died in 1760, was Rector of Omagh and the first of five or six generations of distinguished clergy: the Revd Robert law (1730-1789), the Revd Francis Law (1768-1807), who married Bellinda Isabella Comerford from Cork; the Revd Patrick Comerford Law (1797-1869); the Revd Francis Law (1800-1877); and the Revd Robert Arbuthnot Law (1842-1889).

Another branch of the family included successful bankers. Robert William Law, a first cousin of the Revd Patrick Comerford Law, was the father of Michael Law (1795-1858), of Castle Fish, Co Kildare. He founded the Law & Finlay Bank, and was also a Director of the Bank of Ireland. He married Sarah-Ann, daughter of Crofton Vandeleur FitzGerald of Carrigoran, near Shannon and Newmarket on Fergus, Co Clare, and they had four sons who were successful in their chosen careers.

However, poor health forced Michael Law to close his bank, and on doctor’s orders he left Ireland to live on Continental Europe, where he died while his sons were still children or in their teens: Robert Law (1836-1884) later lived in Newpark, Co Kildare; Michael Law (1840-1905) became a judge in British administered Egypt; Sir Edward FitzGerald Law (1847-1908) is the colourful adventurer who later became effectively the Finance Minister of Greece and the subject of this evening’s discussions; and Sir Archibald Fitzgerald Law (1853-1921) was a colonial judge in Malaya.

Edward FitzGerald Law was born on 2 November 1846 in Rostrevor House, Co Down, the third son among the nine children of the banker Michael Law and his wife Sarah-Ann FitzGerald.

Michael Law the banker died before Edward’s 12th birthday. His widow sent Edward to school in Brighton and St Andrew’s. Then, as an impoverished youth, Edward Fitzgerald Law secured an education at Sandhurst and entered the Royal Artillery in Woolwich Barracks in 1868. But he was son invalided home from India, and a after a brief, four-year military career Law became the British consul at St Petersburg in Russia.

Law then travelled the world as a financial diplomat, an adventurer, a journalist, a failed entrepreneur, railway pioneer, and – I am sure – a spy, working in Russia, Sudan, India, China and North America, before moving to Constantinople, and going on to work in Greece, Bulgaria and other parts of the Balkans.

He moved to Russia to work with the Wire Transport Co. He spent the next 10 years in Moscow, where he became a business agent for agricultural machinery, travelled widely as the Daily Telegraph correspondent, and spent a brief period from 1880 to 1881 as the British Consul at St Petersburg.

He returned to London, where his views on Russia were published in the Fortnightly Review. He then moved on to the Congo, and in 1885 he returned to the British army to take part in the Sudan expedition under Sir Gerald Graham. He took part in the Battle of Suakin, was decorated, and was promoted major.

After this military interlude, Law returned to his travels, visiting Manchuria, San Francisco, Japan and Vladivostok, before returning to London as manager of the United Telephone Co.

Back in London, Law vehemently opposed Gladstone’s Home Rule Bill of 1886. But he was soon travelling again, and by 1888 he was back in St Petersburg as the British Commercial and Financial Attaché to Russia, Persia and Turkey.

The move to Greece

Law first went to Greece in 1892, and presided over the finances of Greece, restructuring the Greek debt and the nation’s economy, to the lasting advantage of Greece.

The Greek treasury had been depleted by over-spending and systemic corruption often caused by political campaigns in which parties promised massive spending programmes. The reformist Prime Minister, Charilaos Trikoupis (Χαρίλαος Τρικούπης, 1832-1896), stood before parliament and made the most famous statement of his career: ‘Regretfully, we are bankrupt’ («Δυστυχώς επτωχεύσαμεν»).

In 1893, Greek taxation was moderate in comparison to many other European countries. Law suggested increasing it, along with introducing reforms in the imposition and collection of new taxes. He regarded a new loan for Greece as a necessity, but the operation was to comprise funding the floating debt, and reducing the circulation of Greek banknotes during the three following years.

Law’s own views were summarised in his covering letter with his report:

If it be held that the difficulty is solely due to unsuccessful financial administration, a further question arises are the resources of the country sufficient, with reasonable care, to meet existing difficulties, or is the financial position so compromised as to be beyond remedy without prejudice to the honour of the Greek nation and the legitimate rights of its creditors?

Law’s report was leaked in the City in London before it was published, causing considerable speculation in Greek stocks. This ‘regrettable incident’ was attacked in the London daily newspapers, and Law was subjected to some unmerited censure.

However, his report helped restore public confidence in Greece, the servicing of foreign loans was suspended, and all non-essential spending was cut. Some of the results Law might have been expected were frustrated by the untimely fall of Trikoupis and his reformist government.

Edward Law and Catherine Hatsopoulou around the time of their marriage

Law was at his happiest in Athens. At a party at the German Embassy there he met Catherine (Kaity), only daughter of Nicholas Hatsopoulos. She was the descendant of an old Byzantine family that was long-settled in Athens. Edward and Kaity were married on 18 October 1893.

Lady Law on a medallion struck for the Empress Frederika in 1894

In 1894, Kaity was the model for an image of Athens on a medallion struck for Queen Victoria’s daughter, the Empress Frederika (1840-1901), wife of Kaiser Frederick III.

Law stayed on in Greece, and in 1897 he was appointed the British member or commissioner on the International Financial Committee at Athens. He remained the British Minister Resident in Athens from 1898 to 1900.

The harbour at Chania … Edward Law used his position in Athens and in the Balkans to assist the struggle for autonomy in Crete (Photograph: Patrick Comerford)

Reading through Law’s papers, it appears obvious that he used his position in Athens and travelling through the Balkans to supply crucial information to the Greeks involved in the struggle for autonomy on the island of Crete. This struggle began 100 years ago in 1897 and resulted first in an autonomous Cretan state headed by Prince George of Greece in 1898, and eventual unification with Greece in 1908, the year of Law’s death.

Death in Paris

From Greece, Law was sent to India, where he was the Financial Member of the Council of the Governor-General, effectively the Indian Finance Minister, from 1900 to 1904. Law is also credited with the invention of a flying machine.

His intention was always to return to live in Greece in his retirement. When he retired in 1905, he remained a director of the Ionian Bank in Greece. But he never enjoyed good health, and he died of a heart attack at the Hotel Bellevue, in Avenue l’Opera in Paris on 2 November 1908, his 62nd birthday.

Earlier that year, his beloved Crete had achieved total unification with the modern Greek state.

Saint Paul’s Anglican Church, Philellinon Street, Athens … Law’s funeral service took place here on 21 November 1908 (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

Law’s own request was to be brought back to Greece and to be buried in Athens. He was given a funeral with full military and state honours on 21 November 1908, with Crown Prince Constantine (later King Constantine I of Greece) and the entire Greek cabinet attending his funeral service in Saint Paul’s Anglican Church on Philellinon Street, between Syntagma Square and the Plaka, in Athens.

Law had been knighted in the British honours system, as a Knight Commander of the Order of St Michael and St George (KCMG) in 1898 for his work in Greece, and as a Knight Commander of the Order of the Star of India (KCSI) in 1906. But he had refused all honours offered by the Greek monarchy and state.

Nevertheless, his coffin was covered with the Greek national flag, and he received a state funeral with all the honours reserved for someone decorated with the Grand Cross of the Saviour, an honour he had declined.

The graveside eulogy in the First Cemetery was delivered by the Finance Minister and future Prime Minister, Nikolaos Kalogeropoulos (Νικόλαος Καλογερόπουλος, 1851-1927). It was reported that ‘… when the soldiers fired the last salute over his Athenian grave, his wife knew that the desire of his life had not been denied him.’

One Greek newspaper, Neon Asti, commented: ‘… he loved Greece with the devotion of a son … he was a Greek at heart. As he felt for Greece, more than a Greek, he watched over her, advised her and warned her …’

Sir Richard Church’s house in the Plaka, beneath the slopes of the Acropolis (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

Close-by in the same cemetery is the grave of Sir Richard Church (1784-1873), the Cork-born general who commanded the Greek army throughout the Greek War of Independence. Church lived in house in the Plaka, beneath the slopes of the Acropolis, and he too was buried from Saint Paul’s Anglican Church on Philellinon Street in Athens.

Οδός Λω Εδουρδου … the street signs on the street named after Edward Law (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

A year after Law’s death, the city council agreed unanimously to name a street in central Athens after him: Edward Law Street is off Stadiou Street (Οδός Σταδíου), the major street linking Omonoia Square and Syntagma Square.

But we all encounter the difficult strangulations when English-language names are transliterated into Greek and then transliterated back into English lettering without considering the original name. So, Edward Law Street in Athens has become Οδός Λω Εδουρδου. There is no W in Greek.

Οδός Τζορτζ … named after Sir Richard Church (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

In a similar way, Byron Street in the Plaka is still rendered Odos Vyronos in English lettering, while in the streets near Edward Law Street we have Church Street, named after Sir Richard Church, which is actually spelled Odos Tzortz (Οδός Τζορτζ), and we get Gladstonos for Gladstone, while Canning has become Kaningos.

The tablet in Saint Patrick’s Cathedral, Dublin, commemorating Sir Edward Law (Photograph: Patrick Comerford)

There are tablets to his memory in Saint Paul’s Anglican Church, Athens, and in Saint Patrick’s Cathedral, Dublin. The memorial plaque in Saint Patrick’s Cathedral, Dublin, reads:

To the memory of Major Sir Edward FitzGerald Law, KCSI, KCMG, late Royal Artillery, third son of Michael Law of this city and of Glenconway Co Derry. Born at Rostrevor Nov 2 1845. Died in Paris Nov 2 1908. Buried at Athens. Served in the Egyptian campaign of 1885. As Financial and Commercial Secretary, he represented his country in various negotiations in Eastern Europe, was First President of the International Commission at Athens 1897, Minister President 1898, Financial member of the Governor General’s Council in India 1900 to 1904. ‘Who shall ascend into the hill of the Lord or who shall stand in his holy place. He that hath clean hands and a pure heart.’

The Biblical reference is to Psalm 24: 3. At the top of the plaque is a coat-of-arms quartering the arms of Law and FitzGerald. At the bottom is the emblem of the Royal Artillery.

The grave of Michael Augustine FitzGerald Law in Duleek, Co Meath (Photograph: Patrick Comerford)

At the time of Edward Law’s death in 1908, his eldest brothers, Robert and Michael, had already died. Robert Law (1836-1884) of Newpark, Co Kildare, was the father of Michael Augustine FitzGerald Law (1861-1917), of Bearmond, Drogheda, who is buried in the old churchyard in Duleek, Co Meath, with other members of the family, including his wife Mary and their son, Major Francis Cecil Law, who died in 1958.

Law was still remembered with pride in Greece when the Church of Ireland Archbishop of Armagh, John Allen Fitzgerald Gregg (1873-1961), visited Athens 66 years ago in 1951. When the Mayor of Athens was told of the archbishop’s kinship with Law, he invited Gregg to return as the guest of the municipality. Gregg later described this as ‘an offer which I fear I cannot hope to take advantage of.’

Meanwhile, other members of the Law family are buried in the graveyard beside the ruins of Saint Mary’s Abbey and the former Church of Ireland parish church in Duleek. As I strolled through the former churchyard in fading lights one evening last year, I noticed a plot with three graves belonging to members of the Law family: Michael Augustine Fitzgerald Law (1861-1917) and his wife Mary (died 1937), Olive Law and Major Francis Cecil Law (died 1958).

The graves are beside one of the ‘short’ high cross, dating from the ninth century and one of the great high crosses of Duleek. These graves are also a reminder of the story of an Irish banker and army officer who saved the finances of Greece over a century ago and who is buried in Athens.

Drishane Castle, near Millstreet, Co Cork (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

Michael Augustine FitzGerald Law, of Bearmond, Drogheda, was the father of Captain Robert Law (1890-1973), of Rosnaree, Slane, Co Meath. I was reminded of Robert’s story earlier this summer when I was visiting Millstreet, my mother’s home village in north Co Cork.

Robert Law was brought up in Drogheda and educated at Haileybury. He was an officer with the Royal Dublin Fusiliers during World War I, and was decorated with the Military Cross.

After World War I, it is said, he shot 12 bull elephants in West Africa but was charged by the thirteenth which left him badly mauled. When he emerged from the jungle with a hoard of ivory, he claimed he had survived on a diet of bananas only.

Shortly after, he eloped with the former Audrey Beatrice Jean Wallis (1888-1961) of Drishane Castle in Millstreet, Co Cork. She left her first husband, Francis Ivan Oscar Brickmann, Robert sold Bearmond, and the couple moved to Rossnaree, near Slane and Newgrange. Audrey’s divorce came through in 1921, and they were married within weeks on 4 June 1921.

Audrey Law died on 28 October 1961. Her son, Major Michael Law (1923-1975), was the father of Robert Law (1955-2004), who married Aisling Stuart, daughter of Imogen Stuart and great-grand-daughter of Maude Gonne.

The Law family continues to live at Rosnaree, which has featured on RTÉ television as a country house wedding venue and is known for its summer art schools. The family portraits there include Sir Edward Law’s father, the banker Michael Law.

Sir Edward Fitzgerald Law’s biography by Theodore Morrison and George T. Hutchinson, The Life of Sir Edward Fitzgerald Law, was published by Blackwood in 1911.

In a chapter contributed to this book, James Louis Garvin (1868-1947), the editor of the Observer and the son of an Irish labourer, describes Law as ‘fearing no responsibility yet able to show himself … a safe and dexterous tactician, and audacious in instinct, prudent in method, and yet full of emotional strength, of passionate possibilities, and all manner of great-heartedness.’

(Revd Canon Professor) Patrick Comerford is Priest-in-Charge of the Rathkeale and Kilnaughtin Group of Parishes and Canon Precentor of Saint Mary’s Cathedral, Limerick. He is a former professor in the Church of Ireland Theological Institute and Trinity College Dublin.

Seeing a Roman arch
instead of walking on
the beach in Rimini

The Arch of Augustus, dating from 268 BC, is the most important Roman site in Rimini (Photograph: Patrick Comerford, 2017)

Patrick Comerford

Because Bologna is so far inland, I thought I might get a walk on the beach in Rimini last week, either on my way to San Marino, or the way back.

Rimini, a city of about 225,000 146,000 people on the Adriatic coast, is one of the best-known seaside resorts in Europe. The sandy beach stretches for 15 km and there are more than 1,000 hotels, and thousands of bars, restaurants and discos.

The story of Rimini as a resort dates back to the 1840s, but this also a city with important Roman and Renaissance monuments, and the hometown of the Italian movie director Federico Fellini.

This part of the Italian peninsula was a part of Etruscan civilisation until the arrival of the Celts, who held it from the 6th century BC until their defeat by the Umbri in 283 BC. But the city of Rimini dates from 268 BC when the Romans founded Ariminum. After Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon, he made his legendary appeal to the legions in the Forum of Rimini.

The Arch of Augustus, built in 27 BC, is the most important Roman site in the city. The arch was dedicated to the Emperor Augustus by the Roman Senate in 27 BC and is the oldest surviving Roman arch.

The arch marked the end of the via Flaminia, which connected the cities of Romagna to Rome, and spans the modern Corso d’Augusto – the ancient decumanus maximus, which led to the beginning of another road, the via Emilia, which ran north-west to Piacenza.

The Arch of Augustus has a single gateway that is 9.92 metres high and 8.45 metres wide, and its style is simple but solemn.

The large central arch is flanked by two engaged columns with fluted shafts and Corinthian capitals. The four clipei or shields next to the capitals each depict Roman divinities, with Jupiter and Apollo on the Roman side and Neptune and Roma facing the city of Rimini.

The gate acted as a city gate, but also supported a lavish bronze statue of Augustus, depicted driving a quadriga.

The arch is also noteworthy because it is especially large for a gate of the time. This may be explanation because the peaceful policy of Augustus, the so-called Pax Romana, made a civic gate that could be closed seem unnecessary as there was no danger of attack.

The battlements on the upper part of the arch date from the tenth century, when Rimini was held by the Ghibellines. The arch was restored in the 18th century by Tommaso Temanza, and it remained one of the city gates until the Fascist period, when the city wall was demolished and the arch was left as an isolated monument.

When the Ostrogoths conquered Rimini in 493, Odoacer, who was under siege in Ravenna, was forced to capitulate. During the Gothic War (535–554), Rimini was taken and retaken many times. Later, under the Byzantine rule, Rimini belonged to the Pentapolis and was part of the Exarchate of Ravenna. During the later wars of the Popes and the Italian cities against the emperors, Rimini sided with the emperors.

Sigismondo Pandolfo Malatesta was the most famous mediaeval ruler of Rimini. In 1463.

Rimini fell to the Borgias, and then to Venice (1503-1509), but it was later taken by Pope Julius II, and the rule of the Malatesta family finally came to an end in 1528.

As a secondary town in the Papal States, Rimini was ruled by an Apostolic Legate.

Napoleon’s invading army passed through Rimini in 1797, Rimini became part of the Cisalpine Republic, and the ancient cathedral of Santa Colomba and many other mediaeval churches and monasteries were demolished.

Rimini was incorporated into the modern Italian state in 1860. By then, the city was being transformed. The first bathing establishment was founded in 1843 Rimini was on the path to becoming a tourist resort. The seafront developed rapidly, and the Grand Hotel was built near the beach at the beginning of the 20th century.

Rimini suffered during the two World Wars, but after its liberation in 1944 rebuilding began, and Rimini became one of the most popular tourist centres in Europe. In the 1960s, Federico Fellini, who was born and raised in Rimini, set many of his moves in his home town.

I never managed to get to walk along the sandy shores of Rimini last week, but I did get to see the Arch of Augustus. Today it is one of the symbols of Rimini today, along with the Bridge of Augustus and Tiberius, and it appears on the coat of arms of the city.